In recent months, Disney’s penchant for “reimagined” adaptations of its animated classics has been a hot topic among fans and critics alike. The announcement of a live-action version of Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs has reignited accusations of “cash grab” live-action remakes among other issues.

As a lifelong fan who has favorites from every Disney decade back to the 1940’s, I advocate for nuanced views about nostalgia and updating classics. Some still like to say the company hasn’t been great since Walt Disney died—but that was 55 years ago, in 1966.

Clearly most of Disney’s highest-grossing (1994’s The Lion King), award-winning (Who Framed Roger Rabbit), and groundbreaking (2018’s Black Panther) films were produced in recent decades.


Every good movie requires so many elements to really work, starting with a clear director’s vision, talented well-cast actors, and a strong script. Even those of us skeptical of live-action remakes can appreciate outrageously villainous Glenn Close in 101 Dalmatians, director David Lowery’s fresh take on Pete’s Dragon, or the lavish visual and thematic work of 2015’s Cinderella.

Future projects too hold promise. From what we know about The Little Mermaid from Rob Marshall—an accomplished musical director who brought Mary Poppins Returns, Chicago, and Disney’s TV Annie to life—we have reasons to be hopeful and reticent to pass advance judgment.


That said, it’s obvious to everyone when Disney has dipped into the nostalgia well one too many times. The following five films and TV projects are remakes and sequels that almost nobody asked for.

1. Turner & Hooch (coming July 23rd, 2021)

Does Disney Plus need more live-action series that have wide appeal? Yes, desperately so (like these). it’s also true that past films have been a starting point for great shows such as NBC’s Parenthood or Cobra Kai on Netflix. That said, who exactly is clamoring for a 1989 comedy to be remade as a limited series?

To be sure, Tom Hanks’ classic film is a goldmine of laughs and hopefully the world rediscovers it thanks to the attempted reboot. Maybe I’m wrong and the Josh Peck-fronted series brings a fresh comic take to the buddy-cop genre. But previews so far indicate this is a retread without the creative spark of the film it’s based on.


2. Beauty and the Beast Prequel Series (expected in 2022)

So get this: someone has convinced Disney to spend tens of millions on a Beauty and the Beast prequel series without beauty or beast anywhere in sight. It’s no joke. Reprising their roles from the 2017 film, Luke Evans will star as Gaston and Josh Gad as Le Fou in a limited eight-episode series that will explore their relationship (or something?) prior to when the characters played antagonists on the big screen. Alan Menken has even written new songs for this limited series.

Even with Once Upon A Time producers Edward Kitsis and Adam Horowitz behind it (great show btw), count on many to pass on this peculiar prequel when it lands next year. It’s not the only pointless “side quest” on-screen adventure being discussed. There’s a blink-and-you’ll-miss-him character named Prince Anders in 2019’s Aladdin, and actor Billy Magnussen has been angling for Disney to give him a spin-off movie. Please someone kill it.

3. Home Alone 6 (expected December 2021)

Since launch, Disney Plus has smartly produced a new Christmas film each holiday season. After all, the company has a rich history of fun seasonal films—though many remain missing on the streamer. Both 2019’s Noelle and 2020’s Godmothered have been utterly forgettable … but maybe they’ll breakthrough this year with Home Alone 6? Don’t bet on it.

The original two Macaulay Culkin films from writer John Hughes and director Chris Columbus will never be topped. Several have tried, with a third theatrical movie in 1997 followed by two made-for-TV Home Alone cheapquels. Disney execs, we know the marketing guys tell you nostalgia IP is all that matters … but for the love of Marv, tell a new story.


4. Alice Through the Looking Glass (2016)

Discussion of huge Disney flops usually center around John Carter and Treasure Planet, ambitious films the studio had trouble marketing. When it comes to Alice Through the Looking Glass, a sequel to the 2014 film, one wonders how such a mess of bad scripting, fantasy clichés, and a worst-ever Johnny Depp performance got the green light.

It’s a shame because Walt Disney Studios has deep legacy ties to the Alice stories by Lewis Carroll, back to Walt’s original 56 Alice comedies from the 1920’s. (Several of those short films were remastered in 2016 by a movie studio in France, but haven’t released to streaming.) The modern spin on Alice replaced the imagination and charm of the source material with force-fed themes that kept audiences away from the sequel.

5. Lilo & Stitch (live action film in active development)

After CGI-heavy remakes of questionable artistic merit earned $1 billion at the box office — looking at you, 2019’s The Lion King — it’s inevitable that Disney will continue to strip-mine its animated catalog for any titles of potential live-action value. Currently, over a dozen such films are in various stages of production, with a couple so outrageous (Chip N Dale Rescue Rangers? Hercules from the Russo Brothers?) they might be worthwhile for laughs.

None of the proposed remakes sounds as bad as Lilo & Stitch, an animated comedy beloved for its outlandish hodge-podge of sci-fi, Hawaiian culture, big-hearted themes of family, and wall-to-wall Elvis tunes. It’s obvious this level of zany doesn’t lend itself to live-action. Rumored director Jon M. Chu of Crazy Rich Asians fame knows his stuff, and hopefully has the good sense to exit this project.


 

Do you agree that some Disney live-action remakes have no good reason to exist? Comment below with your thoughts.








Josh Shepherd

Freelance journalist Josh M. Shepherd writes about culture, faith, and public policy issues. His work has been published by outlets including What’s On Netflix, The Federalist, Family Theater Productions, and Faithfully Magazine. A graduate of the University of Colorado, Josh and his wife live in the Washington, D.C. area with their two children.

Related Article

Write a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

6 Comments

  1. ScionStorm July 3, 2021

    I feel like this is the most pessimistic article I've seen on the site... but don't necessarily disagree with. Except for Godmothered. That was a perfectly quaint movie that felt like a Wonderful World of Disney TV film that could air on the old ABC Family channel.

    1. ScionStorm July 3, 2021

      And actually I wouldn't mind an animated series spin-off in the world of Godmothered based on the final animated sequence. Seems like a lot of fun possibilities to play around with for an original animated series.

    2. Josh Shepherd July 24, 2021

      Godmothered felt like the first draft for an Enchanted sequel... very repetitive of that concept, which Enchanted executed much better.

  2. Steven Jarvis July 3, 2021

    Godmothered was decent and had a quaint charm to it similar to the Disney Present films on ABC in my childhood (which reminds me that those are still mostly conspicuously absent on the streamer). Can't wait for the Beauty and the Beast prequel. That is an original story, original music and something I want out of Disney Plus. I am also interested in the Lilo and Stitch, but understand most people might be indifferent to that.

  3. george July 6, 2021

    B&TB prequel with Luke Evans sounds good tho? And this spin-off to Aladdin also is interesting because it will be like a whole original story with new character

  4. Tom July 7, 2021

    These all exist for very good reasons, to create more content for Disney+ and to make money for Disney. You can take your logic and use it against half the Disney back catalog. Did we need a sequel to the Apple Dumpling Gang? Was the world really wanting that many Herbie sequels? Why were all the straight to video sequels made ? You have to understand that Disney+ said they are going to have 100 new shows and/or movies on the service every year. That means for every Mandalorian or Wandavision, there will be a bunch of reboots like this. And that is fine. Some people really like family friendly movies and series and these fit that bill. Just like the majority of the Disney Channel shows and movies, these are not meant to be masterpieces, just family friendly entertainment. And in that regard, I think they are fine.